CivicActions culture is what makes this company so special. We aim to define the culture and address common questions from potential hires and current team members in this handbook.
The CivicActions culture is one of openness and authenticity. We are radically transparent in our communications and intentions. We strive to create an environment where people are comfortable to show emotion and be our true selves. We are people first, who want to work in a diverse environment that strives to make the world better but who also want to care for ourselves and each other. We are balanced by knowing and honoring the priorities in our lives -- at work, at home, and in our mental and spiritual well-being. As a mostly remote firm, with a few onsite teams, we value promoting and fostering this culture so that it is cohesive and that each team member feels included.
We don't view failure as something to be avoided -- rather, we welcome it as a learning agent and a catalyst for growth which is a foundation of our radical transparency. We don't cast blame when things go wrong -- rather, we strive to learn and to provide support to those affected. We have strong emotional intelligence and we look within to better understand what's happening around us. Communication is our most valuable tool and we practice it openly. We give thanks, we teach, we offer feedback, and we ask for help.
When we say that the culture is what makes our company special, we don't mean to be exclusive. Our culture is also our transformation agent. We hope that anyone we interact with, from clients to co-workers to competitors, will take the openness of our culture with them -- to their home and family, to their next job, to their community groups. It's a way of being that leads to transformation by hiding little, building trust, and embracing change.
Communication based on radical transparency is the backbone of our CivicActions culture -- it's the foundation on which we build healthy, productive relationships with each other and those we work with.
In projects and engagements, our dedication to transparency builds trust between us and our clients. We strive for "no surprises" -- daily sharing updates so that everyone has a clear understanding of challenges, successes, and next steps. Our clients appreciate having first-hand knowledge of project status, and often act as our partners by contributing to solutions. Avoiding an "us vs. them" mentality, we view our clients as allies, and aim to understand their viewpoint in every situation. When conflict arises, as it inevitably will, this open-minded communication allows us to arrive at common ground more quickly.
Within our own team, we take responsibility for learning to communicate effectively and to be aware of how our communications are perceived, staying attuned to the unique needs of each individual person. For example, does the person like to talk pleasantries first, or just get down to business? Do they prefer written or oral communication, and what times of day do they prefer to be contacted? Are they a fast talker or do they absorb information better in a slower-paced conversation? Making an effort to understand how different people communicate can benefit all our relationships -- both old and new, at work and home.
This intentional awareness also extends to people who aren't comfortable or accustomed to the level of openness that we embrace at CivicActions. Our goal is to create safe spaces where we can all discuss the value of open communication and seek to grow our communication skills -- with full appreciation of every person and respect for where they are on their journey. Similarly, our communication processes work to break down barriers that might hinder participation and work to engage the whole team.
Nobody is a perfect communicator, and we recognize that there are many "ideals" for what this perfection might even look like. That said, we do expect everyone to work to strengthen their and CivicActions' dedication to transparency. The more diverse our team and clients become, the better we must become at listening actively and communicating openly.
We invest extra effort into our communication strategies because we are a mostly-remote team (with a couple of onsite teams) and rarely have opportunities for in-person communication. Here are some of the tools and practices we use to help us remain open with each other:
- Slack channels and Email lists - We communicate in a group setting, reducing the need for one-on-one communications that can lead to silos or keep people out of the loop.
- Daily scrum calls on video - Everyday, each team member meets to report on what they did yesterday, what they plan on doing today, and whether they have any blockers. This is an opportunity to offer support and hold each other accountable. It also builds team camaraderie by having a daily forum to look at each other and connect.
- Active Listening - Talking "at" each other doesn't always result in a shared understanding. By repeating back what you are hearing from the other person, you are able to verify that you understand them and give them a chance to correct any misunderstandings or wrong assumptions.
- Tensions - A tension is any issue or reflection we have shelved, buried, or simply not thought to share. Our practice at CivicActions is to recognize when we have a tension concerning a team member, and ask the person if we can share it in a safe conversation where the sole purpose is to clear the air and both parties agree to simply acknowledge the tension and then close the conversation. When we share in this objective way, we clear our minds of anything that might interfere with being able to hear what the other person is saying. When we have shared a tension we might have with someone, we can then be present to who they are in this moment, rather than the story we have been telling ourselves about them.
- Retrospectives - These occur at the end of each sprint on a project level, or at other milestones for any department or activity at CivicActions. It's a forum to talk about what is working, what isn't, and what we can improve. It's a safe space to discuss failure without blame and to reflect on successes and celebrate team members too. We also use retrospectives for annual reviews.
- Balance Scores - At every meeting, we each report our "balance score" -- a number from 1 to 10 that represents how well you are recognizing and honoring your priorities in your personal, work, and spiritual life. Everyone knows about the struggle for "work-life balance," and this practice is our way of empowering people to honor theirs -- with the addition of spiritual/mental health as well. A high balance score doesn't necessarily mean everything is going perfectly in your life, but it means you are honoring the priorities you have set for yourself. By hearing the balance of other team members, we can remain attuned to who might need extra support, or who is thriving and might have capacity to serve as a resource for others.
- Culture Videos - Captured at the 2016 retreat, we have several videos that feature team members talking about CivicActions. It's an interesting glimpse into the different values and appreciations from our peers. We invest a lot of energy into appreciating each other and creating a company where people are free to be themselves and grow their skills by taking risks and learning from failure.
Being a gender-diverse team means that not everyone's pronouns are immediately obvious, so it's important to find out. Taking the time to learn and use your teammates' personal pronouns correctly will help you communicate respectfully.
Sharing your own pronouns promotes clarity and transparency and can also promote inclusion by normalizing the practice. Good places to communicate your pronouns are: your Slack profile, email signature, business card, CivicActions staff bio (if already published, request the addition in #content), or in spoken communication where you feel it is appropriate.
These practices won't be familiar to everyone, and it may take some time and practice to get used to. That's ok — there are plenty of resources and people here to support you as you learn.
Resources Check out the All Hands Call slide deck on personal pronouns to learn more about:
- What are gender neutral pronouns?
- Why do personal pronouns matter in our industry?
- What to do if you mess up
- How to make a correction
If you have questions, concerns, or just want to practice, you can DM a designated DEI point person listed in the #dei-practice-area channel description for support.
What is Radical Transparency?
We talk a lot about radical transparency here at CivicActions, but what is it? There are many different, often conflicting definitions for transparency in business. Here are some, from the book Accountability and Transparency for Peaceful Development by Kelly Ngyah.
You can read the relevant sections for free here.
"Transparency means operating in such a way that others can actually see how, what and why actions are carried out. As a principle...managers and directors of companies and organizations and board trustees have a duty to act visibly, predictably and understandably in order to promote participation and accountability that is deemed ethical."
"Radical Corporate Transparency...is a philosophical concept regarded as the removing of all barriers to free and easy public access to corporate, political, and personal...information, and the development of laws, rules, social connivance and processes that facilitate and protect such an outcome."
How does Radical Transparency Work at CivicActions?
Here's a real life example: In May of 2017, CivicActions experienced significant financial losses. Aaron and Henry presented an All Hands Call in which they laid out the problem, the cause, and the potential actions they would take if the issue was not resolved.
You can view those slides here.
In this example, the company's management team felt a responsibility to be transparent about the health of the company to everyone working at the company.
You can find more examples of our transparent practices and how they can help transform government in this blog post from a CivicActions team member: What "fierce openness" can do for government
How does Radical Transparency NOT Work at CivicActions?
Radical transparency can sound pretty uncomfortable. Some companies take it to mean sharing of salaries, etc. to increase competitiveness. This is not the CivicActions definition of radical transparency. We believe radical transparency is the company, board, and management team's responsibility to be open and transparent with employees, clients, and one another. We believe everyone in the company is responsible for being direct and transparent when they have a challenge with someone. We believe that whenever possible, work should be carried out in public slack channels, problems should be shared with product owners, and issues should be talked out openly and honestly. This does not mean that you cannot ever speak privately to other people. This simply means that CivicActions feels that as a team, it is our responsibility to be as transparent as possible about the work we do, and how we do it.
Inclusion is a sense of belonging that allows people to fully engage and contribute, and is a key part of fostering diversity and equity on our team. Promoting inclusion goes beyond simply tolerating differences — it requires taking an active role in honoring the variety of experiences we bring to the table so everyone is empowered to participate.
Some practical tips for making inclusive spaces on your team:
- Observe your teammates' personal pronouns
- Notice who isn't speaking, and give them opportunities to contribute
- Celebrate the things your teammates do well
- Start noticing when you've made an assumption, and ask questions instead
- Practice active listening (see the previous section)
- Take time to learn more about how inequality affects people at work
- Speak up when you notice that someone is disrespected or left out
We work to model the change we want to see in the world, and that starts with how we make space for each other at work. At CivicActions, diversity, equity, and inclusion isn't just a core part of our culture, it's also a practice area. We meet once a month to work on our current initiatives.
Q: What are some keys to success at CivicActions?
A: The most successful team members at CivicActions embody the culture. They have high emotional intelligence, are active listeners, are introspective and reflective, embrace failure, and do not tolerate a blame culture. It's also helpful if you have "self-starter" tendencies and enjoy taking initiative -- while also being a great team player.
Q: Who can I go to for help?
A: We get it. Any new job can be scary, and starting a new job remotely can be even more overwhelming. If you need help, we want you to know that there are resources available.
- If you want help with your work, your team, your project, etc: Go to your PM, someone else on your project team, or your mentor.
- If you feel unbalanced: Go to your PM, mentor, supervisor or Elizabeth
- If you are being harassed or feel uncomfortable or unsafe: Go to Elizabeth or anyone else on the management team.
Q: What is CivicActions doing to foster diversity?
A: We are actively looking to recruit diverse team members, and we are having on-going discussions about what diversity means and how to foster it. These discussions happen at our annual in-person retreat, during All Hands Calls, during check-ins and via our Slack channel #diversity-equity-inclusion. And we need help with this - we hope you'll join in on the conversation.
Q: Open communications generally make me uncomfortable and I may feel intimidated asking a question in front of an audience. Can I just go to the person who I know has the answer in a more private way?
A: The idea behind our open communication policy is to keep the team in the know and keep information transparent in our remote environment. Since we're not all sitting in an office together, it can be easy to miss out on information. You may ask a coworker a question in a private message, that could have been answered better had the team seen it. Also, your question may be shared by other team members who would appreciate hearing an answer. In many cases it's okay to go to a person privately; what we want to encourage is for people to default to open and to realize that being uncertain or having an issue isn't something to hide. We don't have a CYA mentality -- that only leads to misunderstandings growing deeper and mistakes growing worse. The benefits of open communication extend to our clients as well -- people we work with know that we will not gloss over the truth, but rather be transparent and learn from mistakes.
Q: Balance Scores make me feel self conscious. I don't want people to know that I'm unbalanced. How is the company using this information?
A: The Balance Score is mostly for yourself. It's a way to check in with yourself, sometimes multiple times a day, to realize if you are aware of and honoring your priorities. The company doesn't use this information, unless we frame it as a way to teach team members how to be more self aware or to be more attuned with each other. If you're unbalanced and don't want to discuss it with anyone, you're welcome to say so if someone asks why your score is low. The Balance Score is another way that we can learn to be more in tune to ourselves and have a better understanding of our peers. It's an authentic way of communicating that can feel uncomfortable at first but hopefully becomes an exercise in being attuned to oneself. If you feel uncomfortable reporting your balance, try watching the balance channel for a few days, and seeing the diversity of balance scores makes you more comfortable.
Q: Sometimes we need to put the client in their place. What can we do so that they don't take advantage of us?
A: The company mission of transformation starts with people. With our expectations of good communication and authentic relationships, it can be frustrating when a client doesn't reciprocate with the same openness. This is where the "us vs. them" can start showing up. Instead of "putting the client in their place" we aim to understand where the client is coming from. What is bringing up this behavior? What is causing the fear or distrust? Once we can acknowledge and identify these very real feelings, we get back to being on the same team. We can also look within ourselves -- for example, if our concern is that we're being taken advantage of, why do we feel that way? In an escalated situation, it's not up to a single team member to remedy the situation, but rather to use the support of the team and the account management to get to a healthier relationship with the client.
Q: I've made a mistake in my work and I don't want to use our group forums to talk about it. Can I just ping my manager directly?
A: Yes, of course you can ping your manager directly about it. Depending on the issue though, it may subsequently be discussed openly. If it's something related to development, your peers may have made the exact same mistake and have the solution you're looking for. If it's project budget related, we may want to present it to the PO immediately along with a plan of action on what steps we suggest taking next. The reason most people feel uncomfortable with sharing their mistakes is that they come from environments where failure isn't acceptable. That attitude is neither realistic nor helpful -- so at CivicActions we learn from failure and from each other.
Q: On a project team, who is accountable for what? I want someone to be held responsible.
A: In short, we're all responsible for the success of the project. Commitments are made individually during our daily standups and sprint plannings. Certain roles may have certain responsibilities, but the make-up of a team is more indicative of who will be responsible for what based on the skills between team members. If there is something specific that is making you uncomfortable or if there is someone specific that you feel should be accountable for something, that should be brought up. A project manager can be very helpful in identifying and remedying issues -- but that doesn't mean it is their sole responsibility to do so.
Q: I find all the Slack communications overwhelming. I prefer to read only what pertains to me. How can I manage this?
A: Slack can be great for keeping us all connected on project status, company announcements and a good laugh -- but yes, it can be overwhelming. There are only a few channels that you must review. These include #announcements and your project channels. For everything else you can either leave the channel, mute the channel, or set your preferences to only ping you when your name is mentioned. It can also be relieving to remove Slack notifications from your phone's home screen or using the DND after working hours. There is a delicate balance to all of this, since Slack really is an amazing way to stay connected to your teammates. We recommend trying out different methods for keeping it effective. It would be great to find at least one channel that is more of a social outlet to build camaraderie with your peers. If you're still struggling with managing Slack, please bring it to the attention of your manager.
Q: What topics are inappropriate to discuss at work (eg Slack, meetings, etc.)?
A: Although CivicActions as an organization promotes free & open communication, there are some topics that can be sensitive in a work environment. Talking about politics or religion can be offensive to some. At CivicActions, we don't have a specific list of off-limits topics, but we strive to be conscious of appropriate vs. inappropriate or emotionally reactive topics. The people involved in conversations are expected to be aware of their audience and remain sensitive to how their words may affect others. If you sense that a certain topic might be sensitive to certain coworkers, don't discuss it with them. If you observe or are part of a conversation that makes you uncomfortable, you can bring that up to the people involved or reach out to your manager and ask them to.
The work that we do in serving others and bringing transformation to the world will sometimes require the discussion of sensitive topics. And because our company is comprised of mission-minded people who care deeply about making an impact, there are bound to be conversations that must be handled with care. Our goal is to balance meaningful communications with the understanding that opinions may vary -- and an awareness that some topics can be powerful and unwelcome at work. We want to be open to learning from each other, while increasing our empathy for those around us.
Q: But really, what about politics?
A: Political discourse affects everyone differently. While we want people to be able to have open, respectful conversations about things they disagree about, CivicActions recognizes that political speech can be hurtful and make team members feel unsafe at work. For that reason, we ask everyone to keep political speech to the dedicated #politics channel, and only engage in conversations about politics when you are sure that it is a welcome topic for everyone present. When in doubt, it is best to avoid politics at work.
Many topics can have a political dimension. These guidelines specifically apply to political speech that is expressed in support of a current candidate for political office. If you observe someone make a political statement outside of the politics channel, or introduce unwelcome political discourse into conversation, you can remind them to take it elsewhere by saying, "hey, let's move this political conversation to #politics," or "that sounds like a discussion better left to the politics channel."
Q: Someone put something in Slack or said something at a meeting that I find very offensive. What should I do?
A: If you're comfortable communicating directly with the person who offended you, please start there. You can tell them that what they said was offensive, how it made you feel and why it's inappropriate (this can be done in the form a "withhold" conversation as mentioned above). If you're not comfortable addressing them directly, you can ping or talk to Elizabeth or Owen (or anyone on the management team) and they can help you resolve the issue.
You can also reach out to a Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) point person who is committed to providing confidential support for team members who want to talk through conflict or issues with a trusted peer.
We highly encourage everyone to get support about anything that makes them uncomfortable, especially as our organization grows in numbers and diversity. CivicActions is a place where each team member sincerely desires the well-being of others, and everyone should feel free to speak up without fear of repercussion.
Q: If someone says something that could be interpreted as racist, sexist or otherwise inappropriate, how can I let them know that isn't welcome here.
A: A technique that seems to work well is to just simply say "we don't do that here." This usually gets the person to realize that what they were saying was inappropriate and unwelcome and doesn't put you in a position to have to explain anything. It's simple and to the point (and easy to remember!)